Career derailment strikes high-potential leaders precisely when they seem destined for the top. This happens during critical transitions requiring fundamentally new skillsets. A primary derailment point occurs when technically brilliant, independent achievers – often stellar individual contributors or functional experts – are promoted into roles demanding heightened interdependence. Here, success pivots from personal expertise and direct control to orchestrating outcomes through others. Leaders who thrived by solving problems themselves must now master influencing without authority.  Building coalitions, negotiating across silos, and navigating complex stakeholder landscapes are new to them. Failure to shift mindset and acquire these relational and political competencies leads to isolation, missed goals, and frustration.  The lack of these capabilities derails promising careers built on technical prowess alone.

The second perilous juncture arrives at the pinnacle of leadership, where the environment becomes intensely politically charged and hyper-competitive. Reaching senior executive levels demands far more than functional excellence; it requires sophisticated political navigation. Leaders must decipher hidden power structures, manage conflicting agendas among powerful peers and board members, build strategic alliances in ambiguous contexts, and champion ideas persuasively in high-stakes, zero-sum situations. Overconfidence from past success, underestimating the political complexity, a lack of strategic networking, poor stakeholder management, or an aversion to necessary power dynamics can prove fatal. Leaders derail not from lack of vision or intelligence, but from an inability to effectively apply political acumen to build consensus, secure resources, and protect their initiatives within the intricate power web of the C-suite. They become casualties of the very environment their previous independence ill-equipped them to master.

Prevention & Mitigation:
Organizations and leaders can combat this by:

1. Proactive Assessment: Identifying high-potential leaders’ political and influencing skills before promotion to interdependent roles.
2. Targeted Development: Providing training in negotiation, stakeholder management, organizational dynamics, and coalition-building.
3. Strategic Mentorship/Sponsorship: Pairing leaders with seasoned executives who can guide them through political landscapes.
4. Mindset Shift Coaching: Helping leaders understand that interdependence and political skill are not “dirty” but essential leadership tools at senior levels.
5. Feedback Mechanisms: Implementing robust 360-degree feedback focused specifically on influence and political navigation effectiveness.

It is crucial to recognize that derailment often stems from a skills gap in navigating interdependence and politics. It is not from a lack of technical or operational competence.  This applies to both individual career sustainability and organizational success in cultivating effective senior leaders.

About Author

Fay Niewiadomski

I awaken leaders to purposefully discern the best way forward, with such clarity, that they find within themselves the courage, wisdom, and compassion to do what they never dared to do before.

I’ve been privileged to work closely with C-level officers, presidents, ministers, global chairpersons, diplomats, board members, senior business and political leaders, and their teams to successfully navigate complex, high-stakes situations and make sound business and personal decisions resulting in profound and lasting change.

See author's posts